Okładka książki
Książka po angielsku
Did the Prophet Really Say It
Opis książki
DID THE PROPHET REALLY SAY IT?BRWhen Tradition Became ShariaBRA sentence is spoken.BRA man hears it.BRAnother man remembers it.BRAnother repeats it.BRGenerations pass.BRThen, centuries later, the sentence returns wearing a different robe: BRThe Messenger of God said...BRBut did he?BRThis book puts that question on trial.BRStructured as twenty-one courtroom hearings, Did the Prophet Really Say It? examines reports attributed to Muhammad not by beginning with the assumption that they are false, but by asking a more difficult question: BRHow much certainty can the evidence actually bear?BRThe court opens files on reports concerning women, sex, punishment, apostasy, stoning, slavery, medicine, disease, the unseen, angels, devils, animals, embryology, memory, and human error. Then it turns from the content of the reports to the machinery that carried them across the centuries: chains of transmission, narrator reliability, transmission by meaning, conflicting wordings, forgotten reports, hidden defects, and the judgments of later critics.BRThe prosecution does not need every narrator to be a liar.BRThat would be the easy case.BRThe harder possibility is that they were human.BRHonest men forget.BRTrustworthy men disagree.BRA narrator may preserve the meaning and lose the wording.BRA critic may prefer one version over another.BRA report may be classified as authentic without becoming a recording of the seventh century.BRAnd when historical probability remains historical probability, another question becomes unavoidable: BRWhat happens when probability becomes Sharia?BRWhen a report concerns a minor ritual detail, uncertainty may remain a scholarly problem.BRBut when the same mechanism is used to justify killing, stoning, corporal punishment, sexual access to captives, slavery, or permanent judgments about half of humanity, uncertainty acquires a victim.BRThis book does not ask the reader to conclude that Muhammad said none of these things.BRIt asks for something both simpler and more demanding: BRDo not claim that he said them with more certainty than the evidence allows.BRThe final judgment is not the court's alone.BRIt belongs to the reader.
- ISBN-13
- 9798171567965
- Język
- Angielski
- Waga
- 898 g
- Oprawa
- Miękka
- Wydawnictwo
- Amazon Digital Services LLC - Kdp
- Liczba stron
- 760
- Rok wydania
- 2026
- Kategoria
- Religia, filozofia i duchowość
Przewidywana wysyłka: do 19 dni roboczych
Zwykle wysyłamy wcześniej.
Wszystkie podane terminy wysyłki liczymy w dniach roboczych.